David
Vanderhaar Hunter
CHI
430
Final
Paper
Luo
Laoshi
Social Media in China
The advent of social media is the
wave of ages. Instantaneous, personal, diverse communication between people of
the world and citizens of nations and members of groups with sturdy ideals has
ushered in and maintained a new era of free speech, lively criticism, and great
expression. Social media is credited with much agency in today’s social
movements, with both challenging governments, and allowing great volumes of
government propaganda. In China, information
shared through social media and microblogging sites such as Sina weibo (similar
to twitter) and Renren (similar to facebook) are influencing and shaping the
popular opinions of nation and government towards a state that allows greater free
speech and grander freedom of expression. This analysis does not seek to
suggest that a sort of Western-representational democracy is on the cusp of restructuring
Chinese politics and economy; it is simply to show that free speech has been
more intensely and collectively desired by Chinese citizens with the advent and
subsequent popularity of social media. To reach this conclusion one should consider
the current trends of popularity and
usage of social media in China, the purpose
of social media there, and the relationship
between social media and the Chinese government. In addition, to gather
firsthand data and popular perceptions of this thesis, four interviews were
conducted with Chinese students pursuing a degree in the U.S.
The popular trends of social media
usage in China have been rapidly succeeding. According to Digital Jungle’s
research, a marketing agency based in China, there are over 300 million social
media users in China. Well over 50% of all internet users are linked to social
media. Based on a survey of 5,700 internet users in China, 95% of those living in Tier one (Beijing, Shanghai, and Guangzhou), two
(Province capitals), and three (Prefecture level cities) cities are registered
on social media sites. The popularity and sustained usage of microblogging
and other social media sites determines their effectiveness in achieving
whatever purpose for which they are used. These 300 million microbloggers
include and to some extent represent Chinese citizens from virtually every walk
of life whether it is the body of youthful students, government officials, workers,
intellectuals, or entertainers. As well, all four of the interview subjects regularly
use the microblogging service Weibo. An increasingly well-established,
informed, and technically savvy internet population means that the various uses
of social media, especially in regards to how it affects the decisions and
actions of government, are increasingly important.
Each interviewee was asked why they
used social media and all responded that it is a way to quickly and over long
distances gather information as well as communicate with friends. To a similar
question they responded that it is good
also to share information, emphasizing this information exchange mainly as
political awareness and major new happenings. Two subjects mentioned that
social media, for China, is a great way
to “monitor the government” as civilians. In an article titled Anger, Political Consciousness, Anxiety, and
Uncertainty Zheng, professor and director of the East Asian Institute at the National University of Singapore,
provides and weighs the politica implications of use of sites such as weibo in transferring political
information and breaking news. He says, “ although the government has tightened
political control and media censorship, social networking sites have helped
social groups to organize collective protests.” He describes a well-founded
netizenship that debates issues, asks questions and responds to suggestions of
other users all hours of the day. Zheng gives a host of examples from 2011 in
which citizens successfully expressed their anger and frustration to the
government for mishaps that had taken place within the government and not
followed up with proper accountability. He points out that the emergence and
prolific use of social media sites like weibo
have re-introduced debates on political reform to a much wider spectrum of
society (Zheng, 2012).
Avant-Garde artist Ai Wei Wei has become
one of the many well-known online activists in recent years, and an exemplar in
using social media to freely speak about normally controlled subjects. His
definition of art “has always been the same. It is about freedom of expression,
a new way of communication.” His emphasis on freedom of expression styles the
very heart of Chinese popular desire today. Where the CCP is concerned about
rising social instability, as former Chairman Hu Jintao expressed in 2011, Ai
Wei Wei and other activists are concerned with “taking contradictions and
making them public.” He states, “if a society is unwilling to admit its own
defects, it is perhaps a society unwilling to progress.” Interestingly, Ai Wei
Wei’s socio-political logic echoes older, now less-displayed, ideals of the
CCP. During the Cultural Revolution criticism and self-criticism were revered
as two of the highest values, promoted by Mao himself but today are treated as
formalities. One scholar has recently presumed, “In present day China, as the
Communist Party attempts to reign in rampant corruption and repair the breakdown
of trust between the party-state and society, it continues to emphasize the
practices of criticism and self-criticism as fundamental to the party spirit (党性) and cadre training (干部培训).
According to a June 2010 article on how to train future cadres, the principal
of the Shandong LiYi Prefecture Party School urged cadres not to be ‘afraid of
exposing and never conceal the truth of our own shortcomings and mistakes.’”
And he continues that there is a gap between “ the Communist Party's
rhetoric (praising criticism and self-criticism) and practice (maintaining the
appearance of unity and stability at all costs),” (Critical Inquiry, 2014).
What can continue to fill this gap is an active, widespread and encompassing
use of information sharing via social media; because the media’s effectiveness
in representing and practicing free speech lies in its ability to
simultaneously reflect and create public opinion (Liebman, 2005).
Over the last decade and a half Chinese
media conglomerate have developed national social media sites and applications,
however microblogging sites like weibo
are not as accessible to international communities, thus limited in scope for
worldwide information and opinion sharing. When the interviewees were asked if popular, worldwide social media
sites such as Facebook and YouTube should be allowed in China, one student
responded that these sites should not be allowed because “Chinese people are not ready for them. Many people in China use social
media as a vehicle to express their political articulations; and Chinese people
always prefer rumors [rather] than rational thinking,” (Interview, 2014).
Another student shared the belief that “Chinese people are not yet ready” but
did not state why. The final two opposed these opinions claiming that “it is
good to communicate with people from other countries. Also knowing what we have
and they don't or other way around will be useful information to know if our
lifestyles are good or not.” They
emphasized sites like Facebook and Youtube being “globalized” thus useful for
more diverse sources of information and social, political, or economic models.
Despite opposing perspectives on the
timeframe of China’s allowance of globalized social media, all subjects agreed that it should happen eventually. One student
mentioned that this type of allowance would be a small yet significant step
towards democracy. In “The Wall”,
written by Chang Ta-chuen describing the true events of a Chinese democracy
movement in the 70’s, the students construct a bulletin board that serves as a
platform for sharing ideals and hopes for the future. The students of that time
realized that the board was not a wall but a platform for new ideals of free
speech, democracy, equality, and personal dignity, “’in reality it was only a
wooden board… But, when we wrote on it, it then became a wall, a very solid
wall.’” Of course these social media sites can serve as civilian political or
social platforms promoting needs, desires, and ideas of the people; but even
before packaging the internet as a giant posting wall its abundant and
increasing use should be recognized as the result and action of a platform that
is already popular, swaying China in a direction that deadens censorship and
speaks freely.
Insight into the disagreement, whether
Chinese people are “ready” for these global social media, may be found in
analyzing the 2005 Chinese sing-off Supergirl
phenomenon. This popular television program was the first of its kind to make
it big in China. Even then (in 2005) it could boast large participation
numbers; 400 million viewers during the finale and over nine million votes for
the last three contestants. As related to us by Meng in his article Supergirl as a Media Spectacle, the show
stirred much political debate and garnered two major camps for debate: one camp
which “attribute[s] the success of the program to the voting mechanism, as this
seems to be the only chance for average Chinese to make their voice count,
albeit on an issue totally irrelevant to public policy;” and the other camp
which dismisses those idealized, political implications in favor of the show
being a commercial, media spectacle (Meng, 2009). On one side of the fence we
can say that Supergirl allowed a
large number of citizens to participate in voting via SMS texting; and what is
more is the organizational and campaigning activities that many fans decided to
set up and undergo while the show aired. Supporters formed groups to discuss
contestants on and offline and some scholars deem these activities as
successful democratic exercises. “Journalism scholar Yu Guoming believes that
the show offers citizens the opportunity to see the possibility of practicing
the common values of democracy and equality. Thus a participatory democracy may
evolve from how Super Girls are selected,” (Meng, 2009). The interviewee that
sees China’s allowance of more globalized social media (Facebook, Youtube etc.)
as a step towards democracy answered along the same lines as Yu Guoming
however; media, whether social or televised, is a highly commercial endeavor so
the commodification of shows like Supergirl
must be recognized. In these cases the economy is more highly influential than
government policy and institution. The majority of Supergirl was a commodified product of Hunan Television. Meng
points out that, "to view HTV as voice of people is to romanticize the
strategic move of a newly emerged media conglomerate, which is a competitor of
CCTV more in the economic rather than political sense.” Each SMS vote message
cost the voter 1.5 RMB. Viewer participation in surveilling contestants and
organizing campaigning groups for the show can be realized as contribution of
unpaid labor under the guise of free choice and democratic experimentation. The
sentiments and desires displayed through 2005 participation in this reality
television, to more appropriately put it in perspective, show that the desire
for free speech can be easily misplaced and misdirected under the organization
of overtly economic, commodifying structures; which tends to “reinforce and
naturalize the existing power structure rather than [challenge] the status
quo,” (Meng, 2009). Because of this it is indeed understandable that an
interviewee concludes that China may not yet be ready to accept more globalized
social media. In conclusion, though, the very fact that the Supergirl phenomenon occurred as a
viable economic model, capitalizing on the people’s goldmine of desire for
vocal representation, gives proof of the goldmine’s existence.
The relationship between social
media and the government acts as a valuable gauge with which to measure the
people’s efforts, or lack thereof, to express their freedom of speech. To
understand how social media shapes the government in China is to understand how
the government has shaped it as well; today the two share a strong connection.
Mark Leonard, Director of the European Council on Foreign Relations, said that “the
Chinese state has changed the internet as much as it has been changed by the internet,”
(Leonard, 2013). Ph.D. Professor of Sociology Guobin Yang describes the
relationship “revolution as a Tai Chi-style contest -- a long entanglement of
slow advances and tactical retreats whose result is not determined by a few
strong blows.” These men point out that just as social media in China can be a
vehicle for change from the people, it can just as well be a vehicle for
political stability. In an article titled “The Affluence Trap” by Leonard he articulates
“it is possible that social media could be used to lengthen the life of the
one-party state by giving citizens an outlet for discontent, while allowing the
leadership to understand public opinion (and, if necessary, prevent political
mobilization).”
There are indeed the two opposing forces
at work in China’s social media; the citizens’ free speech and the state’s
censorship. Based on observation though, it is becoming increasingly more
difficult to censor the massive amounts of public data being transmitted every
day. Censorship in the name of stability will become self-defeating resulting
in the “intensification of social tensions.” Leonard shares a recent example of
a Yan’an local official being accused of corruption by netizens on social
media. Instead of an attempt to censor online anger and provide
counter-evidence, this local official was put to blame and ousted from his
position. Leonard says that the “crackdown on the official rather than the
bloggers who exposed him shows that China’s usual approach to stability is
being revisited in the age of social media,” (Leonard, 2013).
In addition, social media sites have
allowed a stronger representation of independent candidates run as they run for
local and provincial positions in the People’s Congress. Scholar Sun shares
that in the 2011-2012 elections sites like weibo
were used by these candidates to update supporters, solicit opinions, share
experiences with other independent candidates, form collective platforms with
others through microblogs, broadcast to the public in real-time so as to unveil
any manipulations or corruption in the poles. Robert A. Dahl says, “the rise of
independent candidates in the election of deputies is a window for observing
the bottom-dynamics of China’s democratic transformation,” (Sun, 2013). In
short, the popular success of social media has since lent its success to the
free voice and election of independent candidates such as Yao Lifa.
Together with the numerous and growing
incidents such as in Yan’an; with the immense popularity of micro blogs and
other social media in China today; with the pointed purpose of sharing
information, monitoring the government, and connecting with people all over the
world; Microblogging and other social media sites continue to shape the popular
opinions of nation and government towards a state that allows greater free
speech and grander freedom of expression.
Works
Cited
Chang, Ta-Chuen. "The Wall." University
of Kentucky Blackboard. N.p., n.d. Web. Mar. 2014
Digital Jungle. "Chinese Social Media
Demographics." Digital Jungle, 2012. Web. 2014.
Leonard, Mark. "The Affluence Trap." New
Statesman 142.5140 (2013): 30-35. Academic Search Premier. Web. 13
Mar. 2014.
Liebman, Benjamin L. "Watchdog or Demagogue?
The Media in the Chinese Legal System." Columbia Law Review 105.1 (2005):
1-157. JSTOR. Web. May 2014.
Luo, Liang. "Ai Wei Wei and the Transformation
of the Chinese Avant- Garde." University of Kentucky Blackboard.
University of Kentucky, Jan. 2014. Web. Apr. 2014.
Meng, Bingchun. "Who Needs Democracy If We Can
Pick Our Favorite Girl? Super Girl as Media Spectacle." University of
Kentucky Blackboard. University of Kentucky, Jan. 2014. Web. Apr. 2014.
Sorace, Christian. "China's Last Communist: Ai
Weiwei." Critical Inquiry 40.2 (2014): 396-419. JSTOR. Web. May 2014.
Sun, Ying. "Independent Candidates in Mainland
China: Origin, Development, and Implications for China’s Democratization."
Asian Survey 53.2 (2013): 245-68. JSTOR. Web. May 2014.
Zheng, Yongnian. "China in 2011: Anger,
Political Consciousness, Anxiety, and Uncertainty." Asian Survey 52.1
(2012): 28-41. JSTOR. Web. May 2014.
Yang, Guobin. The Power of the Internet in China:
Citizen Activism Online. New York: Columbia UP, 2009. Print.
No comments:
Post a Comment